Today in the House of Assembly, Liberal Opposition MHAs asked every PC Cabinet Minister whether they knew when they voted in September to endorse the non-binding Churchill Falls deal that the final agreements would not be brought back to the House of Assembly.
The September resolution only dealt with the one non-binding DCIA, not the 17 final agreements, which still do not exist.
Not one single PC Cabinet Minister answered the question. Instead, we heard more rehearsed and repeated political slogans.
Their failure to answer leaves Newfoundlanders and Labradorians with the understanding that the PCs knew in September they had no intention of bringing the 17 final agreements on Churchill Falls and Gull Island back to the House of Assembly for a fulsome debate and vote by the province’s elected representatives on one of the biggest decisions in our province’s history. Yet, when asked directly in September, they continued to avoid answering the question and hid their plan.
The Official Opposition is also calling on Premier Tony Wakeham to explain why he is willing to be patient with Quebec over the Churchill Falls deal, but refuses to give Newfoundlanders and Labradorians the same opportunity to review, debate, and vote on the final agreement before it is signed.
This morning, the Premier said he was “prepared to be patient” while Quebec considers the Churchill Falls deal. However, that patience does not appear to extend to the people of Newfoundland and Labrador, who have been vocal against Wakeham’s deal and are still being denied an independent review, a referendum, and a debate in the House of Assembly before the 17 final agreements are signed.
“When the PCs voted in favour of the Churchill Falls resolution in September, they were endorsing the DCIA, a non-binding framework agreement. Nowhere in that resolution did it say they were voting on the 17 final agreements, which have yet to be completed,” says Leader of the Official Opposition, John Hogan.
The Premier’s latest comments also raise questions about his changing explanations for rushing the deal. When he announced the agreement in August, he repeatedly pointed to urgency, citing trade tensions and the Trump presidency as reasons Newfoundland and Labrador needed to move quickly. Now, he is telling the public to be patient.
“Newfoundlanders and Labradorians deserve straight answers, and they’re not getting any. In August, we were told time was of the essence and there was no time for a referendum or further review. Now the Premier is prepared to take his time with Quebec, but he still refuses to give the people of this province the same consideration. How can anyone trust a Premier who constantly changes his story depending on what is convenient?” says Hogan.
The Premier also confirmed that the target deadline has shifted from December 31 to March 31. Previously, the Premier pointed to the December deadline as a reason there was not enough time to hold the referendum he promised voters. With that deadline now extended, the Official Opposition is questioning what the excuse is now?
“Once again, the Premier’s excuse has disappeared, but his refusal to let the people have their say remains. If there is now more time to get this right, why won’t he honour his promise? Is he afraid that Newfoundlanders and Labradorians would reject this deal if they had the opportunity to vote on it?”
Yesterday, the Premier told media that “the deal is done,” despite the Quebec government publicly indicating that negotiations are not over and the PCs’ own non-binding framework leaving 17 detailed final agreements still to be negotiated.
“The Premier cannot have it both ways. He cannot tell the public the deal is done while 17 final agreements remain to be negotiated. If the deal is truly done, why is he so afraid to bring those agreements to the House of Assembly for debate and a vote before signing?
Newfoundlanders and Labradorians deserve transparency and accountability on a deal that will shape this province for generations. This is too important for the Premier to make decisions behind closed doors and ask the public to simply trust him,” says Hogan.
-30-